[Phono-L] Re: Edison triumph with totally different upper bedplate

ClockworkHome at aol.com ClockworkHome at aol.com
Wed Nov 14 02:35:18 PST 2007


Watch some poor neophyte collector get into a bidding war over this machine 
thinking it is a rare prototype...   Are we sure the seller is not in India or 
China?  But this is a first, an Edison frankenphono!
 
The cabinet is from 1901-02 with the square corner pillars.  I believe the 
motor is a mix of parts with an early square crank but a later cylindrical 
weighted governor.  I tried reading the serial number on the motor but could not 
ascertain that it was more than only 4 digits.  If only 4 digits it should have 
the hemispherical governor weights.  Anyone with a super digital manipulation 
program?
 
IMHO The machine is no doubt some talented craftsman's project.  I suspect 
the original machine had something heavy fall on it and the castings were 
damaged along with the lid.  If you look, the construction of the topworks is a 
series of metal plates held together with screws.  The stanchions holding the 
backrod are the best examples.  They are screwed on.  The large Concert diameter 
mandrel shaft drive pulley certainly is also odd.  Especially since the 
topworks go around the pulley to allow the mandrel shaft pin bearing to have some 
support structure.  The Model C reproducer without the tracking arm is 
interesting since there was the arm adjusting screw included on the reproducer carriage. 
That Model C with the serial stamped on the horn step rather than just under 
the word "reproducer" means it too is not of the same time frame as the motor 
and cabinet base.
 
This builder was very smart.  Since he could not cast a topworks, he built 
one from many pieces screwed together.  One thing I really like is his method of 
lifting the reproducer with a lift bar activated by the little knobbed swing 
arm under the front straightedge.  Neat but a lot of bench work was done to 
make it all by hand.
 
I would put my money on a craftsman built machine.  Interesting yes, but not 
a rare prototype.  Value?  Who knows?  Historic value without provenance is 
zero but as a conversation piece it could be worth up to the value of the 
reproducer, motor, and cabinet bottom.  The decal looks OK!  Now if they could trace 
the machine to having been made by Al Capone in the Atlanta State Prison 
machine shop and found in his Cicero vault by Geraldo, it might bring some serious 
cash.
 
Regards to all,
 
Al
Phonocurmudgeon...
 



************************************** See what's new at http://www.aol.com


More information about the Phono-L mailing list